How to decide between renovating and rebuilding

There are a lot of things to consider, but we narrowed them all to five, so you can wisely choose between renovating and rebuilding.
How to Decide Between Renovating and Rebuilding

Choosing between renovating and rebuilding your home is a significant decision to make. Both routes are equally daunting. If you are confused about which path to take, weigh these five factors:

1. Costs

It is crucial to think about how the costs will play out in your project. You need to check if you can afford a renovation or a new build, then set your budget.

In many cases, knock-down rebuilds cost less than a renovation. If your renovation involves a lot of structural changes, it might be wiser to start from scratch.

When you decide to knock down the old structure and build a new one, you get to customise everything — the floor plan, orientation, number of windows, number of rooms, etc. 

Moreover, you get to design a home that is sustainable, low-maintenance, high-tech, and energy-efficient. Building and living in this type of structure will make your life better.

New homes also come with a construction warranty. If the builder's works are defective, the homeowner has the right to appeal. It gives homeowners peace of mind.

2. Age of the structure

If you’re planning to live in a heritage home or a character building, renovation is the way to go. We don’t build these structures like we used to, so it’s better to restore these buildings. Yes, it will be super expensive, but you are preserving the nation’s history — and this is more important. 

On the other hand, knockdowns are more suited if there is an ugly home with little or no heritage features on a valuable piece of land.

3. The market conditions

Rebuilding makes more sense if you are living in a populous place where vacant land is scarce (e.g. on sought-after suburbs near the city, bayfront communities, beachfront areas, etc.). There is a little risk of overcapitalising, which happens when the cost of your construction becomes greater than the market value of the house. 

On the other hand, renovations are ideal in smaller, less popular suburbs. 

To find out if you’re at risk of overcapitalisation in your suburb, get advice from your designer and your real estate agent. Your designer can assess the costs of construction, while your real estate agent can give you a clear idea of the market conditions.

4. The block of land

It is simpler and cheaper to work on a flat block of land than on a sloping block. 

Not to mention, there are other matters to settle such as measuring the boundaries, removing troublesome vegetation, setbacks, and the local planning laws. 

Note that every council has a different planning law. It is best to contact them during the design phase. You need to know their inputs before you go ahead with your renovation of rebuild. 

Seek out the advice of your designer regarding this matter too. Discuss the goals of the project then show them the construction site. Your designer can tell you if you should opt for a renovation or a rebuild.

5. The hassle

Think about handling the logistics and the potential emotional toll you and your family might experience. 

Home renovations usually disrupt a family’s daily routine, especially when they have decided to stay on site. If you have young children and senior family members, consider moving out until the builders complete the construction works. 

Knockdown rebuilds require the homeowners to move out. All you need to do is wait for the builders to turn over the key to your new home.

Ultimately, the goal is to get a new home that you and your family will enjoy for a long period of time. Do your homework. And, whichever way you go, make sure you are working with the best design and build professionals. 

Need help with your home project? Get in touch with our senior design consultants. Request a consultation and get a free quote

Liked this article? Follow us on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn.

Contact our Perth-based building designers for more info.



5 Advantages of a Knockdown Rebuild vs Renovation

How to Properly Plan Your Kitchen Renovation

Start planning for free

Find more articles, guides and inspiration in the planning dashboard. Save them to your dream board, and start planning your dream space today.

You may also like

Join our design community

Forgot your username or password?

Download our '5 crucial things you must know before starting any build project' guide for free today

Simply fill in your details below and we’ll send a copy straight over to you

See how much you could save with a free, no-obligation quote today

Simply fill in your details below and we’ll be in touch to discuss your project

  • Drop files here or

Download The Free Guide Now

Fill in the below to get instant access: